An alternative to the employee satisfaction survey
Every year or two, an employee satisfaction survey. The scores look reasonable, the report gets discussed and then little changes. If that sounds familiar, you are not the only one looking for something that delivers more.
This page explains what a satisfaction survey does and does not show, what the alternatives are and why work engagement is a better predictor of effort, staff turnover and results.
What a satisfaction survey misses
A satisfaction survey asks how happy people are with their pay, their workplace, communication and their manager. That helps you spot problems. But satisfaction mostly looks back: how are things now?
Work and organisational psychologist Wilmar Schaufeli describes satisfaction as a sense of being sated. You are content, but it does not get you moving. Work engagement is the opposite: vigor, dedication and absorption in your work. And that is what goes hand in hand with what organisations want to see, such as effort, initiative and people who stay.
What are the alternatives?
If you want to go beyond a satisfaction survey, you usually end up with one of these four options:
- A short pulse survey: a handful of questions, several times a year. Quick, but it mainly shows whether something goes up or down, not why.
- An eNPS: one question about whether people would recommend you as an employer. Easy to compare, but it measures an intention, not behaviour.
- A wellbeing or employability scan: focused on health and workload. Valuable when sick leave is the issue, less so for questions about leadership and culture.
- A work engagement survey: measures vigor, dedication and absorption, and can include leadership and ambassadorship too. That gives you the broadest picture to act on.
Why work engagement tells you more
Gallup compared data from tens of thousands of teams. Teams in the top quarter for engagement had, among other things, 78% less absenteeism and 23% higher profitability than teams in the bottom quarter. That does not prove one causes the other. Still, the pattern keeps coming back.
So a work engagement survey shows how things are now and what you can expect from a team in the months ahead. And it points to where to start.
What to do with the results
Even the best survey achieves nothing if nothing happens afterwards. Share the results quickly, let teams choose one theme themselves and measure again after a while. That way employees see their answers matter, and they will answer honestly next time too.
Satisfaction survey or work engagement survey?
| Satisfaction survey | Work engagement survey | |
|---|---|---|
| Mainly measures | How satisfied people are | How much energy and dedication people have |
| Looks | Back: how are things? | Ahead: what can you expect? |
| Tells you about | Problems with conditions and workplace | Effort, staff turnover and how people experience leadership |
| Result | A list of things to improve | Insight per team to act on: where the strengths and risks are |
The Employee Engagement Survey (MBO)
The MBO was developed by Prof. Dr. Bas Kodden as the successor to the satisfaction survey. It measures work engagement, how employees experience their managers and whether they speak about you with pride. Three scans in one, and it takes employees about 8 minutes.
Frequently asked questions
What is the difference between a satisfaction survey and a work engagement survey?
A satisfaction survey measures how content people are. A work engagement survey measures their vigor, dedication and absorption in their work. Satisfaction looks back; engagement says more about what you can expect from a team in the months ahead.
What exactly is an employee satisfaction survey?
It is a questionnaire in which employees say how satisfied they are with their work, their workplace and their organisation. Read more about the satisfaction survey.
Can I replace our satisfaction survey completely?
Yes. The MBO measures work engagement, leadership and ambassadorship in one questionnaire, and you can add your own questions. That way you keep the topics from your old survey that you want to hold on to.
Can I compare the results with our old survey?
Not like for like, because you are measuring something different. You can carry over questions from your old survey, though. The first round becomes your new baseline; after that you see per team what changes.
How often should you measure work engagement?
Most organisations measure once a year, with a shorter check in between for teams where they are working on something. That shows you whether your actions are working. Read: from satisfied to engaged.